The peer review process for the Malaysian Journal of Action Research is designed to uphold the highest standards of academic integrity and scholarly excellence. It begins with the submission of an original, unpublished manuscript by an author via the journal submission portal, Open Journal Systems. The submitted work must meet the guidelines provided by the journal and align with its scope. The Editor-in-Chief or a member of the Editorial Board conducts an initial review to determine the suitability of the manuscript for further review.

If the manuscript passes the initial review, it is then assigned to at least two independent peer reviewers who possess expertise in the manuscript’s subject area. To maintain fairness and objectivity, the journal operates a double-blind review system, ensuring both the author’s and the reviewers’ anonymity.

The reviewers are tasked with evaluating the manuscript on several criteria, including its novelty, validity, methodological rigour, significance, and quality of presentation. Each reviewer provides a detailed report and a recommendation for acceptance, suggesting either revision (major or minor) or rejection. This feedback is then assessed by the Editor-in-Chief who makes the editorial decision.

If the manuscript requires revisions, the author is asked to address all the reviewers’ comments and revise the manuscript. The revised work might undergo a second round of review if deemed necessary. The Editor-in-Chief then makes the final decision regarding acceptance or rejection of the manuscript.

In the event of a manuscript’s acceptance, it undergoes a final editing process before its online publication on the journal website. Authors also have the right to appeal any editorial decision by providing a detailed explanation for their appeal. This comprehensive process ensures that the Malaysian Journal of Action Research remains an essential source of top-tier research in its field. Authors are urged to adhere to journal submission guidelines and strive to meet the journal’s high -quality standards to increase their chances of successful publication.

 

OJS Editorial and Publishing Process